This is my (not so) "short" list of favorite BPAL scents. Things get moved in and out now and then, so this list is constantly in a state of flux, although most of the older scents are perma-faves.
Bolded scents are ones I would wear any day, regardless of the sort of mood I'm in, without hesitation. I love the other scents, but not everything is something that I always feel like wearing.
Anne Bonny
Aureus
Badger
The Black Rider
Black Temple Burlesque Troupe
Bloodlust
Brom Bones
The Buggre Alle This Bible
Captain Cully
Cathedral
CD023
The Coiled Serpent
Coyote
Dancing Koi
Dark Chocolate, Whiskey and Cognac Truffle
Eat Me
Fenris Wolf
Fighter
51
The Forbidding Foyer
Gothabilly
Hellion
The Infernal Lover (red musk)
The Infernal Lover (no red musk)
Invasion of the Flesh-Eating Reindeer from Uranus
Ivanushka
Tarot: Judgement
Lump of Coal
Lust v7
Madame Moriarty, Misfortune Teller
Mad Sweeney
March Hare
Mole
Monster Bait: Closet
Mouse's Long and Sad Tale (very aged)
Mr. Jacquel
Nonae Caprotina
#OCCUPYWALLSTREET
Paladin
Panther Moon
Penitence
Pinched with Four Aces
Quincy Morris
Rivet.Goth
Rogue
Scherezade
Sin
Snake Charmer
Snake Oil
Storyville
Troll
Tushnamatay
Typhon
Umbra
Velvet Bandito
Voodoo Queen
Western Diamondback
White Chocolate, Black Raspberry and Apricot Cordial Truffle
White Peacock
The second string favorites:
(A lot of these would be in my main favorites box if I had more room. Some are in here because they're too similar to other favorites already in The Box of Awesome and others are here because I really like them, but have to be in the right mood to wear them. Still others are just ones that I wear often enough to want them to be a little more accessible than the scents in my BPAL cabinet are.)
Blue Moon 2004
Boomslang
Calaveras
CD: Misfortune Teller v3
Chaos Theory VI: Recursive Self-Similarity V7 #36
Damnation
Dorian
Elf
Elf v4
Event Horizon
The Forbidding Foyer
Half-Elf
Herr Drosselmeyer
King of Spades
La Mano del Destino
The Lion
Magic, Do as You Will
Marianne
MB: Underbed v1
Miskatonic University v3
Pancake Breakfast
Phyllocrania Paradoxica v1
Phyllocrania Paradoxica v3
Queen Mab
Queen of Spades
Raven Moon
The Red Rider
SAQQARA v2
Stranger in Camp
Tamora
Bold = I own at least one bottle (or at least a partial bottle in a couple cases) of this scent
Italics = I own an empty/tester/very low level bottle
Waiting to be tried:
Aeval
Alice's Evidence
Alien Invasion
All in the Golden Afternoon
Andreiphontes
The Apple of Sodom
Arcana
Baghdad
Baku
Baneberry
Bathsheba
Bensiabel
The Black Apple of Saturn
Black Heart
Black Hellebore
Black Lily
The Black Swan
Bleeding Heart
Blood Moon 2008
Blue Phoenix v2
Boadicea
BRAII (tester)
Cabaret.Goth (sniffie)
Caligula
CD: The Geek Show (unreleased prototype; tester)
Champagne and Party Hats (tester)
Chaotic (unreleased prototype version; tester)
The Chilling Cellar
Chintamani-Dhupa
Cobra Lily
Cockaigne
Cordelia
Couple Consulting an Enpon (sniffie)
Croquet
The Curator
Danube
Dead Man's Hand v8 (tester)
The Death-Horse
Deadly Nightshade Honey
Deep in Earth
The Deep Ones
Defututa
Delousing Powder
Detox
Dia
Diwali (tester)
Dragon's Reverie
Elegy IX: The Autumnal
Envy
Epitaph
Erato
Eros
Ether
Evening Cicadas and Red Peppers
Evil (unreleased prototype version; tester)
Expressive Head
Faeu Boulanger
Faunalia
The Festival of Anuket
The Forest Reverie
Frumious Bandersnatch
The Ghastly Garden
Golden Wave
The Gorobble
Hairy Toad Lily
Halloween: New Orleans
Haloes
Hi'iaka
Horreur Sympathique
Hymn to Proserpine (or Prosperpine...that's what my imp says!)
Iambe
Ichabod Crane
The Ides of March 2010
Illuminati Cotillion
The Isles of Demons
Jerusalem Cherry Infused Honey
Jólasveinar 2010
Khandita
Kitsune-Tsuki
Kubla Khan
Kumari Kandam
Lamia
Languor
La Primavera
Leather Phoenix
Les Bijoux
Les Fleurs du Mal
Liberty
Libra 2007
Love-Lies-Bleeding
Lulu (unreleased prototype version)
Lyonesse
Mag Mell
The Mandrake Charm
Manhattan
Mania
Manipura
Marquis de Carabas
Masquerade
Mead Moon (sniffie)
Miaiphonos
Mictecacihuatl
Molly Grue
Monarch
Moscow
Motley
The Music of Erich Zahn
MVJHL Bake Sale v3 (tester)
Niflheim
The Night Hag Visiting the Lapland Witches
Noisome Clockwork Tin Locomotive
Odd Portents
Ode on Melancholy
Ogygia
Old Demons of the First Class
The Old Goblin
Olokun
Oneiroi
Parthenope
The Phantom Wooer
Philologus
Phobos
The Phoenix in Winter
Phoenix Steamworks
The Piper at the Gates of Dawn (tester)
Pollution
Pontarlier
Pothon Meter
Prurience
Queen Alice
The Reaper and the Flowers
Roses, Pearls and Diamonds
Rozpustnica
Sanctus
The Sea Foams Milk
Sed Non Satiata
Sekhmet v5
Shanghai
Shattered
Shill v1 (tester)
Shoggoth
Silenti (sniffie)
Slobbering Pine
The Sluggard
Smokestack
Smoky Moon 2009: Tristesses de la Lune
Snap-Dragon-Fly
Soothing System v1
Sticky Pillowcase
Stimulating Sassafras Strengthener
Strawberry Moon 2009
Suspiro
Symmakhia
Tabula Smaragdina
Terpsichore
Toad
Toad Hall
To a Woman
The Torture Queen
The Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil
Trinket
The Triumph of Death
Twinkle, Twinkle Little Bat
Uncle Travelling Matt
Unveiled
Velvet Clown
Velvet Unicorn
Verdandi
The Vine
Violet Ray
White Chocolate Mango Buttercream
Whoso List to Hunt
The Wild Swans at Coole
The Witch's Garden
Yürei
On the way:
Dark chocolate with merlot-infused black cherries and star anise
French Tobacco
Mayan chocolate with annatto seed, Anaheim pepper, cinnamon and vanilla bean
Sic Erit
Voyeuristic Monkey
The first part of this list can be found here! I had to split it up because it was getting cut off otherwise.
Purple = love this scent (these are my absolute favorites, the best of the best)
Green = like this scent (there's a lot of variation here, I may like it--even like it a lot--but just don't absolutely love it or I might think it's nice enough but not the kind of scent I enjoy wearing)
Orange = this scent is just okay (I try not to lump scents into this category if I think they're nice but not for me; these are mainly the scents that I don't hate, but can't see a lot of appeal in, on me or on someone else)
Red = don't like this scent (I rarely actively hate a BPAL scent...these are the scents that provoke an immediate "Get it away from me!" reaction for some reason, often because they have almond or rose in them, but those two notes aren't automatic qualifiers for inclusion)
Bold = I own at least one bottle (or at least a partial bottle in a couple cases) of this scent
Italics = I own an empty/tester/very low level bottle
BOOM! Studios:
Bette Noir
Diabolus:
Akuma
Baobhan Sith
Black Annis
Black Phoenix
Black Widow
Blood Countess
Bloodlust
Bluebeard
Catherine
Deimos
Dracul
Ekhidna
Fenris Wolf
Goblin
Hellcat
Hell's Belle
Incubus
Kuang Shi
Kumiho
Loup Garou
Maenad
Malice
Marquise de Merteuil
Masabakes
Medea
Nephilim
Nocnitsa
Noir
Nosferatu
Phantom Queen
Phobos
Rage
Serpent's Kiss
Szepasszony
Troll
Typhon
Unseelie
Venom
Villain
The District:
Countess Willie
Crib Girls
Josie
Doc Constantine’s Pharmacopoeia:
Bruised Violet Compound
Excolo:
Aglaea
Aizen-Myoo
Alecto
Al-Shairan
Anubis
Bastet
Baron Samedi
Centzon Totochtin
Clio
Coyote
Czernobog
Elegba
Eos
Euphrosyne
Eve
Gaueko
Grandmother of Ghosts
Hades
Hecate
Kali
Kurukulla
Lilith
Loviatar
Nemesis
Nyx
Obatala
Ochosi
Odin
Ogun
Old Scratch
Oya
Peithos
Pele
Persephone
Polyhymnia
Queen Mab
Sacred Whore of Babylon
Santa Muerte
Shango
Skuld
Tezcatlipoca
Thalia
Thanatos
Urania
Urd
Xiuhtecuhtli
Yemaya
Gris Grimly:
Detestable Putrescence
Hideous Heart
Hellboy:
Kroenen
Liz
Illyria:
Antony
The Apothecary
Caliban
Desdemona
Goneril
Iago
Jester
Juliet
Katharina
Lady Macbeth
Lear
Oberon
Ophelia
Othello
Queen Gertrude
Robin Goodfellow
Rosalind
Tamora
Three Witches
Titania
Titus Andronicus
The Last Unicorn:
Arachne of Lydia
Captain Cully
Elli's Song
Hagsgate
The King's Daughter
Magic, Do as You Will
The Midnight Carnival
ParaNorman:
Hippie Ghost
The Mad Tea Party:
Alice
Bread-and-Butterfly
The Caterpillar
Cheshire Cat
The Dodo
The Dormouse
Drink Me
Eat Me
How Doth the Little Crocodile
Jabberwocky
The King of Hearts
The Knave of Hearts
The Lion
Mad Hatter
March Hare
The Mock Turtle's Lessons
Mouse's Long and Sad Tale (I only love this when it's very aged, otherwise it's a like, not a love)
The Pool of Tears
The Queen of Hearts
The Red Queen
Rocking-Horse-Fly
Snooty Rose
Tiger-Lily
'Tis the Voice of the Lobster
Tweedledee
Tweedledum
White Rabbit
Marchen:
Baba Yaga (GC version)
Beer From the Marsh Woman's Brewery
Belle Vinu
The Black Rider
The Chicken-Legged Hut
Egle
The Grave-Pig
Grief
The Light of Men's Lives
The Little Sparrow
The Little Wooden Doll (not so great on my skin, but pretty in the bottle or a scent locket)
Moonshine and Mist
The Night-Raven
Prunella
The Red Rider
The Rose
Rumpelstilzchen
The Sea Foams Blood
Serpents with Glittering Eyes and Forky Tongues (kind of in between; I like it but it's bordering on being just okay)
Vasilissa
The White Rider
The Witch's Repast
Neil Gaiman:
Aziraphale
The Buggre Alle This Bible
Crowley
Hunter
The Ifrit (tester)
Ligur
Famine
Hastur
Mad Sweeney
I. The Magician
Mr. Ibis
Mr. Jacquel
The Potters' Field
Shadwell
Sunbird (LE)
The Velvets
War
Panaceas:
Lustration
Moxie
Quietude
Safari
Seduction
Succor
TKO
Phoenix Steamworks:
The Antikythera Mechanism (I'm ambivalent about this one)
No. 93 Engine
The Robotic Scarab (in between liking it and feeling meh about it)
A Picnic in Arkham:
Al-Azif
Arkham
Azathoth
Brown Jenkins
Cthulu
Miskatonic University
Nyarlathotep
R'Lyeh
Shub-Niggurath
Rappaccini's Garden:
Belladonna
Black Hellebore Honey
Black Rose
Blood Lotus
Blood Rose
Bohun Upas
Death Cap
Destroying Angel
Devil's Claw
Dian's Bud
Hemlock
Hemlock Honey
Love-in-Idleness
Mandrake
Mantis
Moon Rose
Shadow Witch Orchid
Strangler Fig
Tobacco Honey
Wolfsbane
Yellow Jessamine Honey
Yew-Trees
RPG:
Chaotic
Cleric
Dwarf
Evil
Elf
Fighter
Gnome
Good
Half Elf
Halfling
Lawful
Mage
Neutral
Orc
Paladin
Ranger
Rogue
The Salon:
And There Was a Great Cry in Egypt
Carceri d'Invenzione
Cloister Graveyard in the Snow
Death of the Grave Digger
Garden Path with Chickens
The Isle of the Dead
The Smiling Spider
Two Monsters
Sin & Salvation:
Anathema
Black Dahlia
The Bow and Crown of Conquest
Cathedral
Damnation
Death on a Pale Horse
Dorian
Fallen
Faustus
Gluttony
The Great Sword of War
Greed
Hellfire (original)
Hellfire (new)
Hymn
Jailbait
Laudanum
Lex Talionis
Lust
Magdalene
Malediction
Nero
Oblivion
Paramatman
Penitence
Roadhouse
Rose Cross
The Scales of Deprivation
Sea of Glass
Seraphim
Sin
Sloth
Tzadikim Nistarim
Vice
Wrath
Somnium:
Nanshe
Somnus
Temple of Dreams
Vampires Don't Sleep Alone:
Tombeur
VILF (the wet stage and early drydown are made of fail, but the later drydown is nice enough)
Wanderlust:
51
Amsterdam
Athens
Bayou
Bengal
Cairo
Crossroads
Delphi
Dublin
Eden
Florence
Glasgow
Gomorrah
The Hamptons
The Hanging Gardens
Hollywood Babylon
Ile de la Tortue (tester)
Kathmandu
Kostnice
Kyoto
London
Machu Picchu
Manila
Morocco
New Orleans
Paris
Port-au-Prince
Port Royal
Rome
Santo Domingo
Silk Road
Sri Lanka
Sybaris
Tenochtitlan
Tintagel
Tombstone
Uruk
Venice
Vinland
Whitechapel
Yerevan
And I saw when the Lamb opened one of the seals, and I heard, as it were the noise of thunder, one of the four beasts saying, "Come and see this list of scents. How the hell could one person have tried that many perfumes?"
Purple = love this scent (these are my absolute favorites, the best of the best)
Green = like this scent (there's a lot of variation here, I may like it--even like it a lot--but just don't absolutely love it or I might think it's nice enough but not the kind of scent I enjoy wearing)
Orange = this scent is just okay (I try not to lump scents into this category if I think they're nice but not for me; these are mainly the scents that I don't hate, but can't see a lot of appeal in, on me or on someone else)
Red = don't like this scent (I rarely actively hate a BPAL scent...these are the scents that provoke an immediate "Get it away from me!" reaction for some reason, often because they have almond or rose in them, but those two notes aren't automatic qualifiers for inclusion)
Bold = I own at least one bottle (or at least a partial bottle in a couple cases) of this scent
Italics = I own an empty/tester/very low level bottle
Exclusives and limited editions:
Limited Editions:
13 (original/white label)
13 (November 2009)
413 U.S. 15 / Miller v. California (tester)
A Bachelor's Dog
Ace of Hearts
All Saints
All Souls
An Altar to Cold, Rigid, Dreadful Death
The Arabian Dance
The Arbor
Atlas
Badger
Bad Luck Woman Blues
Bakeneko
Bitter Moon
Beaver Moon 2005
Beaver Moon 2010
Beltane
Black Temple Burlesque Group
Blood Moon 2005
Blue Moon 2004
Bones Trombone
Boo
Brom Bones
Brood XIX
Buck Moon
Budding Moon
Burning Vulva
But Men Loved Darkness Rather Than Light
Calaveras
Capricorn 2007
Carfax Abbey
The Chained Phantoms
The Changeling
Chaste Moon 2005
Cold Moon
Conical Beast
Count Dracula
The Cracked Bell
Creepy
Dancing Koi
Dark Chocolate, Fig and Tamarind
Dark Chocolate and Key Lime Truffle
Dark Chocolate and Pepper-Smoked Caramel
Dark Chocolate, Whiskey and Cognac Truffle
The Darkling Thrush
The Decrepit House
Ded Moroz
Devil's Night
Diable en Boîte
Dia de Los Muertos
Dr. John Seward
Egg Nog
El Dia de Los Reyes
Enkhespalos
Enraged Bunny Musk
Enraged Groundhog Musk
Enraged Orangutan Musk
F5
Fearful Pleasure
The Feast for the Greatly Revered Ones
The First Soft Snow
Fledgling Raptor Moon
Flower Moon 2005
The Forbidding Foyer
Formula 54
Frederic
Fruit Moon
Ghoulish
Giant Vulva (this one's an odd one; it's between "I like it, but it's not for me" and "meh"...a little too floral for my tastes, but I mostly like it, just not really as a scent for me)
The Gilman House Hotel (sniffie)
Gingerbread Poppet
Gnome
The Goblin Rider
Graveyard Dirt
Green Party
Gunpowder
Gypsy
The Hag
Halloween: Brooklyn
Halloween: Las Vegas
Harvest Moon 2004
Harvest Moon 2005
Havisham
Hearth 2004
Hearth 2005
Hellhound on my Trail
The Hell of Great Heat
Herr Drosselmeyer
Hexennacht 2005
Holiday Moon
Honey Moon
The Host of the Air
Hungry Ghost Moon
Hunter Moon 2005
Hunter Moon 2007
Hygeia
Ice Queen
The Ides of March 2005
Independent
The Infernal Lover (both red musk versions)
The Infernal Lover (no red musk version)
Irrelevant and Disturbing Surreal Crawdad Dream
Ivanushka
Jacob's Ladder
June Gloom 2004
Khajuraho
King of Clubs
King of Diamonds
King of Spades
Krampus (2006 and 2007)
Kusunoki Tamonmaru Masatsura Surprising a Fox Ghost
La Mano Del Destino
Lambs' Wool
Lead Phoenix
La Pere Fouettard
The Last of the Spirits
Lawn Gnome
Lick It
The Living Flame
Love in the Asylum
Lughnasadh
Lunar Eclipse
Luperci
The Lurid Library
Lycaon (tester)
Mabon 2004
Makhanitis
Male Nude, Arms Upstretched
Manilus Hurled from a Rock
Manners Among Men and Women in the Red Light District
Man with Phallus Head
Michael Casts Out All the Fallen Angels
Midnight Kiss
Midnight Mass
Midwinter's Eve
Mi-Go Brain Canister
Milk Chocolate Buttercream
Milk Chocolate, Cassia and Bacon (smells okay one me once it dries, but it's super funky in the bottle and not in a good way)
Milk Chocolate, Coconut, Cardamom, Rum and Ginger Truffle
Milk Moon 2005
Minamoto No Yurimitsu Cuts at the Earth Spider
Minotaur
Mircalla, Countess Karnstein
Mistletoe
Mlle. Lilith, Fortune Teller
Mole
Monster Bait: Bloody Mary
Monster Bait: Closet
Monster Bait: Tokyo Stomp
Monster Bait: Underbed
Monster Bait: Underpants
Monster Bait: Ventriloquist Dummy
Moon of Horses
Mother Ginger
Mother Shub's Spiced Lait de Chèvre (tester)
Mourning Cloak (my bottle says Mourning Shroud
Night's Pavilion
Nonae Caprotina
Nuclear Winter
Numb
The Nutcracker
#OCCUPYWALLSTREET
One to Tie, Two to Win
Orb Weaver
Paduan Killer Swarm
Pallas Athene
Pancake Breakfast
Pandemonium
Panther Moon
Parlement of Foules
Peacock Queen
Penumbra (tester)
Perchta
The Perfumed Garden
The Perilous Parlor
The Phoenix in Autumn
Pinched with Four Aces
Pink Moon 2005
Pink Phoenix
Pirate Moon
Plastic Pink Flamingo
Prosperity of a Country
Pumpkin I 2005
Pumpkin II 2005
Pumpkin III 2005
Pumpkin IV 2005
Pumpkin V 2005
Pumpkin IV 2009
Pumpkin Latte
Pumpkin Queen
Punkie Night
Purple Spotted Swallowtail
Pussy
Queen of Clubs
Queen of Diamonds
Queen of Spades
Quincy Morris
Rat
The Rat King (2005)
Raven Moon
Red Lantern
Red Moon 2004
Red Phoenix
Rhinotoros
Riding the Goat
The Ring
Rose Red
Roux-Ga-Roux
Ruddy Daggerwing
Salamander
Samhain
Samhainophobia
Schwarzer Mond
The School-House
Scorpio 2007
The Sea Rat
The Season of Ghosts
Selkie
Skadi
Sleepy Moon
Smut
Snow Bunny
Snow Moon
Snow White
The Soldier
Spicebush Swallowtail
Spooky
Staged Moon Landing
Standing Female Nude
Stardust
Storm Moon
Stranger in Camp
Strawberry Moon 2005
Sugar Cookie
Sugar Plum Fairy
Sugar Skull
Sylph
Talvikuu
The Ta-Ta
Teatime in Roswell
Thunder and Blazes
Tin Foil Hat (sniffie)
The Traveller
Trick or Treat
The Twisted Oak Tree
Undine
The Unsavory Gravediggers
Valentine of Rome
Variety of Pleasing Amusements
Velvet Bandito
Velvet Cthulhu
Velvet Dogs Playing Poker
Velvet Tiger
Werepuppy
White Chocolate, Black Raspberry, and Apricot Cordial Truffle
White Peacock
Wildfire
WILF
Winter Solstice Lunar Eclipse
Winter-Time
Wolf Moon 2004
Wolf Moon 2011
Wolf Spider
Womb Furie 2010
Wrestlers
Yuletide
BPTP Exclusives:
Bauble (sniffie)
Bogle (tester)
Celeste
Comforting Plush Companion
The Ecstasy of Passion
Egg'd Mailbox
Fee
Hellion
La Fee Verte
The Last Squished Jellybean (sniffie)
Left His Nurse While in a Crowd
Lump of Coal
Marotte
Marshmallow Poof
Monsieur Petitbled's Frivolous Wheeled Footwear
Mitzvah
Ninon
Overprotective Possessed Talking Doll
Playing with Dangerous Toys
Scattered Gloom
Snow Angel
Snowblind
Spanked
Spanked Revisited
TP'd Trees
Trick #2
Uncertain Horror
Retail Exclusives:
Autumn
Banshee Beat
Blackberry Jam & Scones
Black Lace
Creature Feature
Crimson Christmas
Heavenly Love & Earthly Love
Invasion of the Flesh-Eating Reindeer from Uranus
Lucifer
Mutant Hot-Rodders from Hell High
Mysterious Warning (sniffie)
Psychological Horror
Red Lace
Silas Ruthyn
Sue's Great Old Puppet Show
Tattered Lace
Ü
Zombie Apocalypse
Event Exclusives:
The Anti-Saloon League (tester sniffie)
Badgers
Bat of Good Death
Cat Allingham
The Crumpet Rebellion
Doc Buzzard
Dungeon Crawl (tester)
The Elephantine Colossus
Fetish.Goth
Fuwu Bansaku in Ruined Temple with Black Monster on Umbrella
Gothabilly
Ho Ho Ho
India Ink
In Reilig Oran (sniffie)
Mitzvah Gororet Mitzvah (tester)
Mount Misery and Sweet Hollow Roads
Mule Skinner v1
Old Roswell Cemetery
The Phantom Cow of Yerba Buena Island
Pumpkin King
Reindeer Poop
[Rivet.Goth
Romanti.goth
Shanghai Tunnel
Sky City (After)
Storyville
Voodoo Queen
Carnaval Diabolique:
Australian Copperhead
Banded Sea Snake
Bezoar
The Blasphemare Reliquary
Boomslang
The Chapel (tester)
Clemence
The Contract of Theophilus of Adana
Coral Snake
Death Adder
Dionysia
Green Tree Viper
Habu
Hand of Glory
The Illustrated Woman
Inez
King Cobra
Marianne
Meskhenet, the Vulture Maiden
Mme. Moriarty, Misfortune Teller
The Parliament of Monsters
Pickled Imp
Priala, the Human Phoenix
Saw-Scaled Viper
Shrunken Heads
Temple Viper
Thalassa, the Galapagos Mermaid
Theodosius, the Legerdemain
The Two-Headed Goat
Western Diamondback
The Wild Men of Jezirat Al Tennyn
Carnaval Noir:
Bearded Lady
Bed of Nails
Fire Eater
Freak Show
Geek
Gypsy Queen
House of Mirrors
Kunstkammer
Medicine Show
Midway
Shill
Snake Charmer (original and resurrected)
Torture King
A Demon in My View:
Al Araaf
Alone
The City in the Sea
Dreamland
Evening Star
The Haunted Palace
Lenore
The Sleeper
Spirits of the Dead
A Descent Into the Maelstrom:
Berenice
Fortunato
The Masque
Montresor
The Pit & The Pendulum
The Premature Burial
The Tell-Tale Heart
Usher
Springtime in Arkham:
Al-Azif
Arkham Revisted
Shub-Niggurath
Azathoth
Cthulu
Dunwich
Kingsport
Miskatonic University
Tuzscha
Whippoorwill
Yog-Sothoth
Unreleased & prototypes:
300F v1
Abedus Indentatus v5
Amaterasu v3
Antimony v9
Baba Yaga (unreleased version)
Bedbug
Beth's Experimental Blend (one of several)
Beth's Experimental Blend (another of several)
Black Widow Circus
Boomslang v2
Cake Smash v6
Capela dos Osos v5
CBBOB1
CD023
CD: Alley of Games v6
CD: Misfortune Teller v3
CD: Tilt v4 (tester)
Chaotic v3
Decadence
Dorian v2
Dorian v3
Elf v4
Ennui v42
Fenris Wolf v2
The Fire Dancer
Grand Guignol v4
Gun Moll
Half-Elf (unrleased prototype version; tester)
Half Elf v5
Hellion v2
Hexahedraon v3
IXHV4
IXHV37 (tester)
Jingo-Kogo v6 (tester)
KPX130 (tester)
Kweku Anansi
Lamia v3 (tester)
LULU7
Lust v7
Mary Celeste v4
MB: Underbed v1
Miskatonic University v3
Morocco v2
MUV3
NGG023 (tester)
Nigredo v7
Nine Mysteries
Obeah
Osiris v4
P013
Paladin v3
Peace
PEXO
Phyllocrania Paradoxa v1
Phyllocrania Paradoxa v3
PL176 (tester)
PRC12
PX23
PX117
Quick Grope Under the Mistletoe
Ranger v5
Sacrifice
SAQQARA v2
Sol Niger v2
Taphophobia v2
Tetramorph v2
Trachelophorus Giraffe v3
Val Sans Retour
XCDL13
Zombie Apocalypse v4
----
Discontinued lines:
The Atomic Luau Lounge:
Aremata-Popoa
Polynesian Pop (in between "like it but not my kind of scent" and OK)
Rangoon Riptide
Red Tide
Screeching Parrot (sniffie)
The Chakras:
Anahata: The Heart
Muladhara: The Root
Svadhisthana: Sacral
Illumination:
A'Arab Zaraq
Oblation:
Chiroptera
Corazon
Oisin
Thunderbird
The Sephiroth:
Binah
Chesed
Chokmah
Geburah
Malkuth
Netzach
Tiphareth
Yesod
Single Notes:
Blue Lilac
Carnation (tester)
Cinnamon
East African Black Patchouli
Juniper Berry
Pikaki
Pink Grapefruit
Red Mysor(e) Sandalwood
Redwood
Siberian Musk
Sweet Clove
White Cedarwood
Tarot Oils:
Ace of Cups
Ace of Pentacles
Ace of Swords
Ace of Wands
The Chariot
Death
The Devil
The Emperor
The Empress
The Fool
The Hanged Man
The Heirophant
The Hermit
The High Priestess
Judgement / Judgment
Justice
The Lovers
The Magician
The Moon
The Star
Strength
The Sun
Temperance
The Tower
The Wheel of Fortune
The World
Voodoo Blends:
Bat's Blood
Crucible of Courage
Goona Goona
India Bouquet
Juju
----
General catalog (including discontinued scents that are part of current lines):
Ars Amatoria:
Aperotos Eros
Ave Maria Gratia Plena
Bien Loin d'Ici (I like it in the bottle, but it's just okay on me; definitely a scent locket blend)
Bordello
Brisingamen
Carnal
Casanova
Debauchery
Delight
Depraved
Desire
Endymion
Forbidden Fruit
Golden Priapus
Harlot
Hetairae
Ingenue
Jezebel
Kabuki
La Belle Au Bois Dormant
La Lethe
La Petit Mort
Le Serpent Qui Danse
The Lady of Shallot
Libertine
Lolita
Lorelei
Lucy's Kiss
Maiden
Muse
Nefertiti
O
Perversion
Psyche
Queen of Sheba
Rapture
Ravenous
Salome
Saturnalia
Satyr
Severin
Siren
Snake Oil
Spellbound
Succubus
The Temptation
Vicomte de Valmont
Vixen
Wanda
Wanton
Whip
Ars Draconis:
Dragon's Blood
Dragon's Bone
Dragon's Claw
Dragon's Eye
Dragon's Heart
Dragon's Hide
Dragon's Milk
Dragon's Musk
Dragon's Tears
Ladon
Ars Moriendi:
Dance of Death
Danse Macabre
Darkness
Embalming Fluid
Eternal
The Ghost
Haunted
House of Night
Jazz Funeral
Nocturne
Shroud
Silentium Amoris
Tears
Thanatos
Twilight
Wings of Azrael
Zombi
Bewitching Brews:
#20 Love Oil
Absinthe
All Night Long
Anne Bonny
Antique Lace
Arachne
Aunt Caroline's Joy Mojo
Aureus
Belle Epoque
Bess
Black Cat
Black Forest
Black Opal
Black Pearl
The Black Tower
Bliss
Block Buster
Blood
Blood Amber
Blood Kiss
Blood Pearl
Bon Vivant
Brimstone
Burial
Carnivale
Cathode
Chimera
Chuparosa
The Coiled Serpent
Come to Me
Dana O'Shee
Dee
Delirium
Dove's Heart
Eclipse
Eidolon
Empyreal Mist
Event Horizon
Feu Follet
Fae
Fire of Love
Follow Me Boy
Grand Guignol
Grog
Hamadryad
Has No Hanna
The Hesperides
High John the Conqueror
Highwayman
Horn of Plenty
Hurricane
Incantation
Inferno
Intrigue
Jack (I and II)
The Jersey Devil
Jolly Roger
Juke Joint
La Bella Donna Della Mia Mente
La Belle Dame Sans Merci
Lampades
Leanan Sidhe
Lightning
Love Me
Lurid
Magus
Mata Hari
Morgause
Omen
Ouija
Ozymandias
Penny Dreadful
Phantasm
Plunder
Poisoned Apple
Queen
Rakshasa
The Raven
Red Devil
Saint-Germain
Scarecrow
Scherezade
Schrodinger's Cat
Seance
Shadow
Storm
Sudha Segara
Swank
Tempest
Tushnamatay
Twenty-One
Ulalume
Ultraviolet
Umbra
Undertow
Van Van
Velvet
Voodoo
Water of Notre Dame
Wilde
Wolf's Heart
Zephyr
Yggdrasil
The remainder of the scents I've tried can be found here! I had to split it into two posts because it was getting cut off otherwise.
