Torrilin Report post Posted May 27, 2006 Gaueko has a tobacco note. I have no idea if it's similar to Herr Drosselmeyer or not since I don't do LEs, but the scent is amazing. Unfortunately something in it hates my guts, and I can't figure out what. Kalli Share this post Link to post
ayelienne Report post Posted May 27, 2006 Medicine Show has a green tobacco leaf smell to me. Share this post Link to post
zenvodunista Report post Posted May 27, 2006 i think Dee is the closest thing to Herr D. on the GC -- and both i can't wear on my skin. that parchment/book note does bad things on my skin. hooray for scent lockets though! i absolutely LOVE Perversion, its' very much about the tobacco. n. Share this post Link to post
TrailerTrashPrincess Report post Posted June 21, 2006 i also really really like Herr Drosselmeyer. reminds me of my first stepfather and the custom blended pipe tobacco he smoked. there's something in that oil that goes a little bit iffy on me on the final drydown, though, but only *sometimes* i got a bottle of Kether from the Sephiroth collection.... and it turns into all the good parts of Herr D. but none of the bad -- very tobacco leaf, pipe smoke and warm snugglies. that's what i'd suggest [= Share this post Link to post
merivelle Report post Posted June 27, 2006 Thank you Princess (and the other who replied). I have Perversion but on me all I smell is the wine and none of the tobacco. I will check out Kether. Share this post Link to post
melrose Report post Posted June 27, 2006 I second Dee. I have lots of BPAL scents yet to try, but this one is my favorite so far. I never imagined I'd like tobacco scents. Share this post Link to post
sookster Report post Posted June 27, 2006 dee for sure and devil's night... everytime i wear devil's night all the guys tell me i smell like a pipe... Share this post Link to post
Ina Garten Davita Report post Posted April 7, 2008 Havana is my favorite tobacco scent. I adore Beth's tobacco note. Share this post Link to post
Trish Report post Posted April 13, 2008 Havana is one of my new loves, and confirms what I already suspected - I do indeed love tobacco. Especially with that touch of leather and with that muskiness (I know musk isn't listed for it but I would swear it's there). However tobacco does have a tendency to turn dusty on me in the early dry stage. I just have to control my slathering urge, as the more I put on the dustier it is and the longer it lasts. Now... Hellfire you say? Why haven't I tried it yet? I have nothing against the other notes in it that's for sure! Share this post Link to post
martiangurll Report post Posted April 25, 2008 Havana is really yummy and I would recommend A Bachelor's Dog, if you can find an imp. I also like Doc Constantine. I am assuming you mean the tobacco leaf and not the flowers? Share this post Link to post
noirisnoir Report post Posted July 3, 2008 Mr. Nancy is a fabulous, expensive, slightly sweet pipe tobacco on me. Share this post Link to post
Greensleeves Report post Posted July 4, 2008 Gaueko has a tobacco note. I have no idea if it's similar to Herr Drosselmeyer or not since I don't do LEs, but the scent is amazing. Unfortunately something in it hates my guts, and I can't figure out what. Kalli I was really, really excited when I read the description for Gaueko since I am also a lavender fiend, but I am extremely fond of the smell of unlit tobacco. I could sit there and sniff an unlit cigarette for hours. Sadly when I tried out Gaueko I didn't get either lavender or tobacco notes, just incense, which was pleasant enough, but not what I was hoping for. If there ever is a blend where that tobacco note does stand out for me, softened perhaps by some interesting greeny fresh or spicy florals, I am going to be all over it! Share this post Link to post
flco Report post Posted July 23, 2008 My husband was not much of a fragrance wearer until I introduced him to the world of perfumery. Think borrowing his brother's can of Axe when he was going somewhere nice with me. I got him Il Profumi di Firenze's Tabacco, which he wears a lot and it smells divine on him, and he sometimes steals my bottle of Isaac The Living Skeleton (also works really well for him). I made him try The Parliament of Monsters, and although it smells really good, it does something a little bit feminine when it hits his skin. What else should I get for him to try? He amps tobacco in a really delicious, sexy way it seems. Share this post Link to post
Monster Report post Posted July 23, 2008 Have you tried leather scents on him? De Sade is gorgeous on my husband Share this post Link to post
black*cat Report post Posted July 23, 2008 How about The Antikythera Mechanism, it is divine. Share this post Link to post
Ina Garten Davita Report post Posted July 23, 2008 Havana is my favorite tobacco blend. I bet it would be dead sexy on a guy. Share this post Link to post
northatlantic Report post Posted July 23, 2008 Seconded Havana. It's not terribly complex, but it's rich and sensual. Share this post Link to post
Monster Report post Posted July 23, 2008 How about The Antikythera Mechanism, it is divine. I was gonna recommend that as well! Share this post Link to post
phantasmmysteria Report post Posted July 23, 2008 Seconded Havana. It's not terribly complex, but it's rich and sensual. You ladies already covered my two main choices! Havana and The Antikythera Mechanism. Share this post Link to post
brsis Report post Posted July 24, 2008 Tobacco scents are win A few of my favourites: Hellfire, Peversion, Ogun Might also want to try: Dracul, Elegba, Gaueko There's also some great blends with tobacco in the Salons series, they don't get nearly enough love. The other tobacco scents I like are LEs, but if you like LE stalking try Herr Drosselmeyer and Red Lantern (Might be a tad girly, that one, but worth a try I think) Share this post Link to post
flco Report post Posted July 24, 2008 I have Red Lantern '08! It hasn't occured to me that it might work on a guy though. Share this post Link to post
nightbiscuit Report post Posted July 25, 2008 How about Herr Drosselmeyer or Capricorn 2007? You might have to search around for those though. I tobacco note! Share this post Link to post