Failmingo Report post Posted November 16, 2016 Just a note to those who'd want to know: if "butter CO2 extract" is listed as a note in a scent, it is not vegan. We have updated our FAQ to reflect this: "With the exception of our honey-based products and CO2 Butter Extract, everything that comes from BPAL is vegan, and we abhor animal testing. Black Phoenix does not test on animals, and we do not work with companies that utilize animal testing. Black Phoenix is entirely cruelty-free, as our four dogs, many fish, and resident cat will attest. All products are tested on staff, family, and friends. Always double check the ingredients or contact our Customer Service before making a purchase if you are unsure of any components listed in an oil’s listings." We apologize for any confusion or disappointment this may have caused. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites