Numanoid Report post Posted December 21, 2015 Agony and ecstasy: black leather and damp red rose. Can't believe I am first....seem other people would have gotten this already! In the bottle - I get roses...just roses. It is a soft rose, nothing too strong, but it's there. I am worried about it because I am not a rose fan, but most of the time, the HG counterpart to perfumes tend to work. On damp hair - Well, I still get rose. It is kind of nice. I am not detecting the leather in it, but it might be just that note that is keeping the rose from being too overbearing. But like most of us, I am sure, notes we don't like tend to be "overpowering" to our noses. Not sure I want to keep this... it is a perfect HG for springtime.... it is light and rosy, but I was hoping for a bit more of the leather to peek out. If you are a fan of light florals and roses, this is for you! Delicate in fact... to me at least. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
brineydeep Report post Posted December 21, 2015 (edited) I am not detecting the leather in it, but it might be just that note that is keeping the rose from being too overbearing. But like most of us, I am sure, notes we don't like tend to be "overpowering" to our noses. I find this funny because I get plenty of leather from this gloss and wish it had more rose (then again, my dream hairgloss is 100% rose). In reality, I think the balance is pretty good between leather and rose and the two compliment each other well. The rose scent is strong and fresh and doesn't tend toward sweet or sharp or any other the other ways that rose can go. It's exactly what it says on the label: leather and fresh deep rose. In terms of strength, this one is in the middle-to-strong end for throw and has pretty good staying power. I swear I could still catch hints of leather in my damp hair this morning after washing out yesterday's gloss. Overall, I'm glad to have this one in the hair gloss rotation. I think it will get good wear all year round. Edited December 21, 2015 by brineydeep Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Jilara Report post Posted January 20, 2016 How many ways doth rose appear? All forms would smell as sweet... Rose scent is definitely a form of infinite variation, and the rose in this is one that reminds me of my favorite tea rose perfume from Coty, back in the 1970s. The leather is very background, just enough to moderate the rose and give it a warmer depth, and seems strongest when this is first sprayed on. The rose scent is bright tea rose (the old rose tea rose scent, not hybrid tea) and very powerful on my hair. The staying power of rose on my unwashed hair was amazing. On freshly washed hair, the rose fades out a bit after a few hours, and it becomes more leathery. I'm complementing it with Rose Cross perfume, though it can definitely stand on its own. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
zankoku_zen Report post Posted January 27, 2016 Sultry, sexy red rose. In alot of ways, this reminds me to Peacock Queen but when PQ is definitely regal, Whip is sexy. This is the smell of red rose petals that have been f*cked on. Unapologetically, sexy red rose. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
LizziesLuck Report post Posted March 8, 2016 I'm shocked I forgot to review this! I adore Whip, and the hair gloss is totally true to the perfume on me. This is the perfect balance between red rose and leather (and a leather note I can wear, no less!) This is the sexiest rose ever. Whip, indeed! Love it. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
