BeastiestFiend Report post Posted August 12, 2008 (edited) I love gingerale it makes me feel better! I would love to have a nice gingerale scent! any recs for me? Edited August 12, 2008 by BeastiestFiend Share this post Link to post
donnatron Report post Posted August 12, 2008 A challenge! I don't know if we can totally replicate it, but here's a list: Kumiho: Haven't tried it, but it seems simple enough and the combo of tea andd ginger is probably something that we associate with upset stomachs and the like. Siren: My number one recommendation. It's sweet ginger with a touch of orange blossom. It doesn't have the effervescence of fresh gingerale, but it does kind of remind me of flat gingerale. Sadly, that's about all I can come up with. If an imp of Siren floats your way, definitely try it. It's the best GC choice I can think of. Maybe Siren layered with Bon Vivant would give you the effervescence of a freshly opened gingerale? Share this post Link to post
Apple Report post Posted August 12, 2008 This is going to sound completely off the wall, but try Bewitched from the Bewitching Brews category. The first time I tried it, I jotted down that it seemed effervescent and reminded me of ginger ale. I was quite surprised to find that the notes are blackberry, sage, green tea, wild berries and dark musk... ginger isn't even mentioned. A more straight-forward suggestion would be Sudha Segara, also from the Bewitching Brews category: "sweet milk and warm, healing ginger with a touch of golden honey and our blend of Ambrosia". It's not fizzy, but it is gingery. I'd be curious to hear other people's recommendations and the results of your quest. I wouldn't mind smelling like ginger ale myself. Share this post Link to post
ivyandpeony Report post Posted August 12, 2008 Almost every scent I tried from the Tiki Bar collection had a fizzy, effervescent quality like ginger ale bubbles. Share this post Link to post
grashopper8 Report post Posted August 12, 2008 I quit drinking soda (for the most part) years and years ago but now I want a frosty glass of ginger ale Sooooooo freaking bad! I would also love to know what BPAL or layering of BPALs would smell like ginger ale. Keep us posted and let us know if you find what you're looking for! Share this post Link to post
forspecial_plate Report post Posted August 12, 2008 ... A more straight-forward suggestion would be Sudha Segara, also from the Bewitching Brews category: "sweet milk and warm, healing ginger with a touch of golden honey and our blend of Ambrosia". It's not fizzy, but it is gingery. ... I second Sudha Segara, whole-heartedly. To me it even smells a little bubbly, but more like lemon and lime soda than ginger ale. I remember thinking it was way less milky than I was expecting, and much lighter. I don't think I would call it fizzy either. Share this post Link to post
jizatt Report post Posted August 12, 2008 I'm seconding Kumiho - it had the sharp sweet ginger part, but maybe not the bubbles. Sudha Segara was more creamy on me though. Share this post Link to post
Apple Report post Posted May 18, 2009 (edited) Eau de Ghoul! On my skin, it's a fizzy, sweet ginger ale. Even in the imp, it smells positively drinkable. Don't let its rather gruesome description deter you; it's a delightfully effervescent ginger scent. Edited May 21, 2009 by Apple Share this post Link to post
naeelah Report post Posted May 18, 2009 (edited) I can't think of anything I've smelled that is exactly like ginger ale. But, as ivyandpeony mentioned, the Tiki bar scents are very soda-like. Te Po has a lot of ginger and it's probably the most like ginger ale of any BPAL I've smelled, but it has cherry too. (A lot of people think it smells like cherry coke, but to my nose it didn't have that cola quality. Just lots of vodka and ginger, with a twist of mint.) Kumiho is a plain ginger scent but it's clean, lemony ginger. It doesn't have the bite or effervescence of ginger ale, but it's worthy trying. Edited May 18, 2009 by naeelah Share this post Link to post
surlygurl Report post Posted May 18, 2009 Eau de Ghoul! On my skin, it's a fizzy, sweet ginger ale. Even in the imp, it smells positively drinkable. Don't let its rather gruesome description deter you; it's a delightfully effervescent ginger scent. I second this. It's more earthy, like really good ginger beer. But, yeah.... it's yum. Share this post Link to post
fairnymph Report post Posted May 21, 2009 Eau de Ghoul! On my skin, it's a fizzy, sweet ginger ale. Even in the imp, it smells positively drinkable. Don't let its rather gruesome description deter you; it's a delightfully effervescent ginger scent. I was just going to type EXACTLY this. Share this post Link to post
PersephonesChild Report post Posted May 23, 2009 Independent smells exactly like ginger ale, but good luck getting your hands on some! Share this post Link to post
zendadachick Report post Posted October 14, 2011 I have a shower gel that smells exactly like sweet ginger ale, the tang of lime, and the spicy bite of real ginger. It's a refreshing scent. Are there any bpal scents that are similar? Your response is greatly appreciated. TIA Share this post Link to post
tkannon Report post Posted October 15, 2011 Some people say that Gnome in the RPG line smells like ginger ale! Share this post Link to post
wendyb1063 Report post Posted October 15, 2011 It's been a while since I tried them, but Mother Ginger (Yule 2010?) and Playing with a Loaded Gun reminded me a bit of ginger ale. Share this post Link to post
Kayah Report post Posted October 15, 2011 Polynesian Pop from the now DCd Atomic Luau Lounge has ginger ale as one of its notes.. couldn't tell you if it did smell like ginger ale though because my skin chemistry did something awful to it but most reviewers seem to like it as a ginger ale scent.. Share this post Link to post
JasminDreams2010 Report post Posted October 15, 2011 I will second mother ginger, and also suggest Siren. While Siren is a little more warm/ginger/vanilla, I think it might appeal to ginger-ale lovers as well. good luck Share this post Link to post
Antoinette Report post Posted October 15, 2011 (edited) Yes, I second both Gnome and Polynesian Pop. Mother Ginger has a sugary/marshmallow note in it, I don't get ale from it - but, it is divine! Gnome is easy to get a hold of since the RPG line is part of the general catalog. Edited October 15, 2011 by Antoinette Share this post Link to post
Lazuli Report post Posted October 15, 2011 Ditto-ing Mother Ginger. To me it smells like ginger ale plus dreamsicles. Share this post Link to post
darklorelei Report post Posted October 15, 2011 I love BPAL, but I've always been really disappointed in their gingers. I love a really fresh sort of ginger scent, and that's pretty hard to come by in the BPAL line. Baobhan Sith is probably the only one that's not super heavy (to me), but ginger is definitely not at all the dominant note in that scent. Share this post Link to post
rhetoricians Report post Posted October 15, 2011 I will have to try Gnome, too! I didn't know this! Share this post Link to post
Gateau Report post Posted October 15, 2011 Must try Gnome and Siren! Polynesian Pop was ALL ginger ale on me, complete with bubbles. I hardly got any rum or orange. I wouldn't call it ginger ale, but Kumiho is quite gingery, though it's ginger tea. Share this post Link to post
patina Report post Posted October 15, 2011 Gnome's pretty good, though it is peppery. Weirdly, I get fizzy gingerale from Eau de Ghoul. But there's also leather and dirt. Share this post Link to post
PumpkinGuts Report post Posted October 15, 2011 Mother Ginger is ginger ale + marshmallows. Polynesian Pop is brighter and more orangey. Both are fizzy and delicious, though Mama G is more compatible with the cooler weather. Share this post Link to post