In imp: very heavy on the sandalwood, hopefully the prettier scents will come out stronger on skin. Still, kinda like an old blanket that smells a little funny but is too comfortable not to snuggle up in.
Wet, on skin: ugh, it's just not getting any better. It just smells musty and old, but not in a good way.
Drydown: less abrasive, but this might just be a swapper. Too bad.
Dry: definitely not for me. Getting softer, but no better.
sidenote: I made my sister smell it, and she likes it. She couldn't figure it out, either, but she said she'd actually wear it, so giving it to her. After seeing so many suggestions to age it, I'll check back with her in a couple months and see if she has any left for me to try again