Haha, well the *good* news is that your Top 5 has some serious winners in it: Antony is fantastic,and Dorian & Jolly Roger are way up there too. Here are some others in that similar family-ish.
Phoenix Steamworks
Oblivion
Greed
Fascinum *Oooh I had forgotten about this one it's so good!
Golden Priapus
Faunalia
Galvanic Goggles
Dee
Death on a Pale Horse
The Robotic Scarab
Fenris Wolf
Crowley
Loup Garou is a pine, isn't it? There are toooonnnss of pine & forest & tree scents. My favorite tree scent is Yggdrasil, it's not really pine like Loup Garou is though. But. It's fantastic. i also liked Slobbering Pine.
Thank you so much for all of these recommendations! I'm excited to try these out And yeah, Loup Garou is a pine. I smell like a forest when I wear it and I looooove it.