Jump to content
BPAL Madness!

surlygurl

Members
  • Content Count

    2,352
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by surlygurl

  1. surlygurl

    Arachne of Lydia

    Brownish purple is right. Neither is sweet. On my skin, it's sour dust. I do get the fruits and the clove, but the sour is overwhelming. So sad.
  2. surlygurl

    The School

    This must be one of those scent that change wildly from one person to the next. Either that, or it's mislabeled. At first, it's "Ohhhh! Incense! I love incense!" The 'gold coins' warm it up and make it cozy. As it dries, there's something familiar about it, like an Indian Incense vibe. Like a Faces of the Heroine scent. But now it's REALLY familiar, like.... like..... Nag Champa or Super Hits incense. Oh wow. This is so weird. And it doesn't change in the drydown at all. I like incense, but this is too much for a perfume. Maybe it'll age into something else, but right now, not for me.
  3. surlygurl

    Großvater Tanz

    Nutcake!!! I really like this; it's much simpler than other cakey / foody scents. And as it dries, the nuts seem to darken, like they've been toasted. It's not too sweet. The sugar in this is some earthy unrefined thing. I suppose the "cake" is really the grain porridge. The cream is just the glue that holds it all together. So what is this? Just what the description says - toasted nuts, cream & treacle syrup on porridge.
  4. surlygurl

    The Chained Phantoms

    Ice wine like wow! Pretty and only a bit boozy. Something in the throw is a little sour (hello wine!). The sour eventually fades (in maybe 5 minutes) and I *think* the chamomile comes forward. There's less alcohol now. Definitely the frosty white grapes of The Shivering Boy. I don't know what Balsam of Peru smells like, but something is gently grounding this scent. I really like it. Now for the big question: Does the alcohol smell really go away, or did I just get used to smelling like booze?
  5. surlygurl

    Harlequin and Columbine

    OH YUM RED CURRANT!!!! Yup - my first sniff. On my arm, same thing only softer. And sweeter, like red currant candy. I'm guessing that the french vanilla is the thing 'gentling' the currant. There's no wood to speak of, but as it dries, the currant / vanilla combo becomes clearer and brighter. Very pretty, a little tart, not too complex. This would be perfect for my friends teenage daughter.
  6. surlygurl

    The First of the Three Spirits

    Mmmmm! Soft & pretty! This scent is soft white summer flowers. Smelling this on my arm, I picture an old "Summer's Eve" commercial - dark haired woman in a white cotton sun dress swinging on a tire swing under a tree out in a meadow somewhere. This scent is a little tropical and a little innocent. On the drydown, if I sniff up close I get coconut cake! The throw, anywhere in the wet/dry phase, is early summer flowers. Very pretty and very girly.
  7. surlygurl

    The Soldier

    Firstly, the red musk isn't doing what it usually does, which is a good thing. This scent is understated. It's a little juicy, a little fruity, and a touch...... not foody, but sort of bakery like. The leather and pepper are way in the background. As it dries, the red musk tries to muscle it's way to the front, which is bad news for me. But soon the cream reigns in the red musk bully and everything finds itself in harmony. It's quite well blended. The pie comes out once the fighting stops and everything smooths out. It's still not a "me" scent, but the decant is staying.
  8. surlygurl

    The Rat King

    WOAH!!! Is this mislabeled!?? I was all ready for dusty, woody musk and I get a face full of flowers. Strong sweet flowers. If I sniff it up close there's a little soap, but it's still really floral. It's not *bad*, it's just not what I expected. As it dries I can make out some musk, but any wood or dust is missing. It doesn't change as it dries, either. Maybe it'll age into something less flower-bomb-y...... eta: You know what it smells like now (after about a month of aging)? Estee Lauder perfume. My mother's signature scent. She has the perfume & the lotion, and the lotion ends up on all the doorknobs, so I know the scent well. This is spot on *shudder*
  9. surlygurl

    Ekhidna

    This scent is the biggest "wtf!!??" in my BPAL history. When it arrived from the lab, it was dark, gritty, intense. A little overwhelming. Still, I could sense a sweetness underneath it all, so I kept it in hopes it would soften with time. Now that it's aged 6 months or so, it smells like bubble gum . Seriously. Okay... maybe a tiny drop of resins and a tiny drop of vetiver smushed up in a freshly chewed wad of Big League Chew bubble gum. Odd.
  10. surlygurl

    Pumpkin Latte

    Huh. Ok. This is espresso alright. Behind that is a sweetened pumpkin syrup with cinnamon. As it dries, the pumpkin-cinnamon syrup gets stirred into the espresso and the whole thing cools and blends. It's a pleasant smell, and would make a great candle scent or room spray. But on me? A little too foody.
  11. surlygurl

    Ghoulish

    Why did I get this? I do not like cherry. Still..... it's a Halloween scent. Fresh on the skin, it's a cherry cordial. Not as bad as I expected. Even better, the cherry fades into oblivion and almond comes out - a sweet foody almond. I am liking this. Then comes a pastry-type smell. Maybe not pastry exactly, but definitely foody. There's an added sweetness, too. It sort of reminds me of Golletes, but fruitier and not as sour. Much more my speed.
  12. surlygurl

    Golletes

    I wow! This is nice! I wasn't sure what to expect, but I'm getting high-end pastries. It's foody in a classy way. There's a bit of sugar that comes out as it warms up. It's a strange sweet, almost sour, like sour candies. (I expected this sugar in blue pumpkin floss.) Too bad the pastry note is fading. After about 20-30 minutes the pastry note returns - yay!! The sour candy smell wavers, but it remains and tries to blend in to the pastry. Hmm. "Sour sugar" might be strawberries, but like none I've ever tried. Not bad, just not me.
  13. surlygurl

    Pomegranate V

    Huh. From the notes I expected this to be dark & slightly brooding. Instead, I got light, spicy, and slightly powdery. Very little pom (in comparison with #'s 1-4). The spice was carnations & light pepper - a pleasant gentle spice. Someone upthread mentioned High Strung Daisies, and I agree. This had a bit more powder and is more mature smelling. It's a very nice blend, but not at all what I expected. Especially since it fades away after about 20 minutes.
  14. surlygurl

    Pomegranate III

    This one is odd. It starts of all lavender and pom - not a bad blend, but unexpected. Any sandalwood just grounds it. But as it dries down I get something slightly familiar (aha! the tamarind!). This scent doesn't morph so much as reveal itself. There's a little clove when sniffed up close. Cedar is nowhere to be found. This is the strangest scent. Lavender/pom/tamarind is the main thrust. The base notes just kind of shift around. I wasn't too enthralled with this scent, but I keep getting wafts of it and it is so very pretty! It's been on for 3 hours now, and it's sandalwood & tamarind with a touch of herbal pom. Every stage is almost a whole new scent, and they're all pretty. eta: The nuts come out on the extreme drydown. I bet it'll age like woah. Bottle buy! Wow! Was I wrong about this! Now that it's settled & blended, it's nowhere near as spectacular. Still nice, but not a bottle buy.
  15. surlygurl

    Pomegranate II

    This is fun! It's gentle & clean, almost spa-like. Pom, citrus, soft musk. It's so simple. It's young & girlie and conjures up lazy summer days or easter egg hunts or something decidedly non-halloweenish. There may be a bottle of this in my future.
  16. surlygurl

    Pomegranate I

    Fresh on my skin I get the jasmine from Lilith & the Jarocho *wrinkles nose*. But the pom blends right in and makes it all ok. Then I get something... creeping... slowly coming up from behind. It's the benzoin, and it's gently grounding the sweet pom/floral. I could really like this. But the the benzoin takes center stage and does a duet with the pom. Jasmine sits off the side of the stage and pouts. After a bit I think "I could get used to this" when it changes yet again. The benzoin backs off and the pom is the star of the show. Benzoin is still grounding this scent, making it grown up & sexy, but pom is the star. Wow. This needs further testing. Lots of it.
  17. surlygurl

    Pomegranate IV

    Woohoo!! This is very Snake Charmer-esque, but more fruits and less sex. I get no cocoa or tobacco. As it dried I get a funky sharp herbal that blends well with the musky fruits. This is nice. Unfortunately for me, it dries down to just-plain-red-musk, which still hates me. But I tried!
  18. surlygurl

    Thirteen (13): August 2010

    Wow. This is the most un-chocolate 13 I've ever smelled. It smell like fruit. Specifically, like hard candy, like those fruit flavored hard candy stick coated in milk chocolate. Except I don't smell the chocolate. Well, maybe as a grounding agent. This is weird. I'll retest this soon and edit this if need be.
  19. surlygurl

    Blue Pumpkin Floss

    I had such high hopes for this. As soon as it hit my skin, I knew BPF and I weren't to be. Cinnamon. Sugared cinnamon, and butter. All I'd need is toast, and it'd be a great snack. There's no pumpkin to speak of. I want this to work. Maybe the pumpkin will come out with age. As it is, it's not a fave.
  20. surlygurl

    Wildfire

    I was expecting smoke & woods & burning things. What do I get? Dragon's blood. Cloyingly sweet dragon's blood. And soap. Light soap at first, drying down to fancy hotel bathroom soap. Off to the swap box!
  21. surlygurl

    Mabon 2010

    This scent starts with a warm herbal note on top of sweetish liquid - the blackberry wine, I'm guessing. I get the apple cider/grape thing. It smells like an extremely diluted Samhain. I don't really get nuts or woods. Just a watered down Samhain & herbs, which is alright with me. I like it
  22. surlygurl

    Interfector

    Wow! In the vial, it's sharp deep tobacco. Familiar tobacco. But there's something else.... On my skin, the heavy tobacco jumps out right away. Just as suddenly it calms down a bit & something sweet blends with it. Drying down, it gets sweeter, almost a foody sort of sweet. Must be the bunn (a type of taro). The waft from my arms is sweet, but in a slightly evil & dirty way. In my mind, this scent is the color of milky tea, but a touch more golden. I imagine it as being a 'soft' scent, but it still clings to me after a shower. I like it and will definitely wear it!
  23. surlygurl

    Misericordia

    In the vial there was almost no smell. Strangest thing. So I dabbed some on my wrist. HELLO Lavender!!!! It's very dark, somewhat fruity. but Lavender. At this stage it's not so bad. Drying down, I get something a bit powdery and a bit, um, vomity. Could be the castoreum. Wish I could get magnolia and labdanum, but, alas, all I get is fruity lavender vomit . I'll keep the decant and hope for an aging miracle.
  24. surlygurl

    Khandita

    This scent is my very favorite black musk scent so far. It starts off with aged sweetish/powdery black musk with a bit of sharp rosemary and a "shine" from neroli. (I've recently found that neroli is good to me). I do get the rootbeer vibe others mention, but it merely helps ground the scent. This conjures up a picture of a gorgeous, slightly wicked looking woman with a playful smile around her lips & eyes while her mind focuses on revenge. IMO this oil was better - "shinier" and sharper - when it was fresh, but it's much sweeter and less harsh with age. Guess I'd better wear it more often!
  25. surlygurl

    Schwarzer Mond

    So I got this bottle from the lab when it was new. It was *strong* and a bit scary, so I put it away to age. This is one of those scents that aged really well. Fresh in the bottle, it's still dark & scary, like resins & turpentine. Almost unpleasant. On my skin, it morphs almost immediately into something less harsh & a bit sweet. It's still resiny, and the sharp medicinal bit smells like pine sap. As it dries, there's something powdery-sweet going on, floating in and out. There's something in the background that I like but can't place. After a time, the turpentine/ pine sap calms down even more and the "what is it?" scent reveals itself - Cola! I love cola scents! Dry, the cola and the sweet powdery something band together while the scary resins & sap fade into the background. Mostly, on me, this scent is sweet & dirty cola. I love it!
×