vanilla323

I recommend Courtney too. It's one of my favorite bubblegum scents by far!

A Game of Yes and No is a lovely marzipan and mulled wine scent. I haven't tried Eat Me, but it sounds like it would be right up your alley. Dessicated Frostberry Pie Filling might also be worth checking out. A Game Called Yes & No I have tried and ended up selling off...if memory serves I think it lacked staying power on me but did smell AMAZING! Eat Me was the same. Loved the smell but it didn't last. My skin eats things up like crazy! And Dessicated Frostberry Pie Filling wasn't foodie enough it had something weird to it that didn't sit right on my skin. Thanks for all the suggestions though. Love to hear what people come up with based on my list!

My top 5 right now are: Braving The Ice Sweet Lavinia's Dread Puddings Ooky Shortbread Snowflakes BO Dorian in the Pumpkin Patch I would love to hear more foodie recs!!! Also check my collection link to see other bottles I have so you don't recommend scents I already own. Thanks!

Mother Shub's Unmentionable Peppermint Creams is nice if you can do marzipan...

Now were talking that sounds amazing! But of course it's hard to find...maybe one day me and Gothabilly will cross paths...

Bumping this because I was looking for cherry scents and I realized a lot of almond/amaretto scents come out as cherry for some...so if you can think of any foodie almond or amaretto scents that smell like yummy cherry pie please let me know...something foodie and cherry like...I did try Amaretto Christmas Puddin, it was yum but faded fast sadly...

Glad cough syrup works for ya! I guess what I'm looking for is more sweet cherry pie! My hubby likes sweet yummy cherry smells that's why I'm trying to find a yummy cherry pie type scent. It can be LE that's cool too...

I tried Hideous Heart and I think I got cough syrup on that one. Haven't smelled Jester or Kabuki though. Are those foodie cherry?

I gotcha...and the staying power?

I really wanna smell Youth's Disengagement! It sounds awesome! Is it foodie at all????? Not really a fan of star anise either but thanks for the recs...

Looking for some sweet foodie cherry scents...but not cough syrupy. I have tried Cherry Armaretto Puddin, it was yummy but faded fast. What other cherry scents do you all love? I am curious to try Monster Bait: Bloody Mary after reading some of this thread... Any more???

Bumping this thread to see if there are any foodie leathers you all might recommend? I have tried The Soldier and Eldritch Dark. But wondered if there was something sweeter, yummier, but still leathery?

This would be awesome too!

The best coconut I've had so far is from BPTP it's Shortbread Snowflakes bath oil (I wear it as perfume). The notes are Coconut-sweetened shortbread laced with royal icing

Thanks! Great choices!

I have a super short platinum blonde pixie cut and I love foodie scents the most! What would you recommend for me??? I'd love to hear....

I should've listed things I've tried with strawberry. Thanks for the suggestions TheIceMaiden! I added my notes next to each one... BEAVER MOON 2007: This was light on me and faded fast BEAVER MOON 2010: Sold this bottle off because it was more fruity then creamy L'ESSENCE DE L'ENGOUEMENT: Again it was too light for me WHITE CHOCOLATE AND STRAWBERRY: This along with other older chocolate scents got weird on my skin but did smell awesome in the bottle. WHITE CHOCOLATE, STRAWBERRY, AND WHITE PEPPER TRUFFLE This I never tried or smelled so hmmm maybe. I did just get in a bottle of Love (Pickman Gallery) and it's sweet strawberry and vanilla...loving it so far...maybe this is the one!

I really liked Banded Sea Snake and The Malignant Dreams of Cthulhu in Love. I'm not really an aquatic girl but those two are awesome!

I have a odd request for a scent... I want something that smells like Strawberry Milk tastes. Like good old strawberry syrup (or Nestle powder) in milk stir it up and smell! Or something like a strawberry milkshake maybe would work...sweet strawberry (no green) and vanilla. Hope you guys can help...

I'd say try Halfling or Dragon's Milk

annemathematics what a lovely post. You are so right! I gotta stick to my gut. Waiting now for Lupers to show up in case I want one too, but definately thinking I'll get MSUPC! It's the one pulling at my heart strings, making my gut squirm. Been reading all the reviews for both scents and will definately add my review as well when I get the bottle!

I loved Ichabod Crane, but for me it felt more masculine and not too minty.

I wanted to add Eldritch Dark. It's a sexy leather as well.

Hmmmmm...I am so torn on which one to get!! I've been leaning towards MSUPC for lasting power but now I'm confuzzled!!!

Six hours is pretty good not many scents last that long on me anyway! And I echo annemathematics's question about the different mints...please describe!