I really wanted Dwarf because I have a minor obsession with all things dwarfy. Hearing this scent was a bit cologne-y, I got a little nervous, but decided to take the risk anyway!
In the bottle: HOO! The cologne! I was getting disappointed. I could really smell the soot and leather. I wasn't getting a lot of hops or metal filings.
Wet: The cologne-y smell becomes light and not so...cologne-y. Good! The sooty smell became very spicy and kind of peppery. The leather is still there. I can smell the hops better now. The metal never really showed up.
Dry: I don't know why, but the scent became pretty feminine and very sweet-smelling on me. The sooty smell is still there, as is the leather.
Mixed with lawful and ranger, this smell is very intoxicating and relaxing. It's helped me fall asleep two night in a row, now.