I'm very new to BPAL - but have already kind of gone overboard in trying things out. I love "O" and "Bliss". I also adore "Chimera". I like "Alice" well enough, but it's by no means close to the level of liking that I have for the first 3.
"Mouse's long and sad tale" is too flowery/planty for me. Reminds me too strongly of one of the department store type perfumes my mom used to wear many years ago. I wanted to like it, based on the reviews - but my nose is not in agreement.
"Black Pearl" is meh on me. I think I'd possibly wear it at about the same rate as "Alice" - maybe a little less.
From these I've decided I'm definitely a "Foody". Give me honey and other sweet, sugary scents. I'll pass on the plants, musk, patchouli, and whatnot. Additionally - all my life I've been on a lookout for a perfect rose scent. Based off my preference for sweet scented things - decided to give the Faith & Hope set a shot. Although - if it turns out to be a favorite, I'll be sad when it's no longer available. Didn't keep me from ordering it or some of the other LEs though. My reasoning is that if I find I love them, with some help I should be able to find the normally carried oil perfumes that might match up or at least be in the category of things I like a lot - and if I don't like them - they're LEs, so it should be potentially easy to re-home them.
I am currently eagerly awaiting the arrival of:
Womb Furie
Delirium
Bon Vivant
Lemon-scented Sticky Bat
Box of Chocolates: Fig and Tamarind
Box of Chocolates: White Chocolate Mango Buttercream
Nymphia
Young Pine Saplings
Hope and Faith: Siamese Twin Perfume Set
It has now dawned on me that of these, only two of them are regularly sold scents. Doesn't exactly bode well - but I do love having a lot of options to change things out from day to day. A large stash of delightfully tasty smelling perfumes should keep me happy for a loooong time to come.
I definitely suspect that within the next couple of months I will probably have some 5ml bottles and many imps up for swapping