Some lovely fairies gifted me with various aquatics to get me started on my BPAL journey, and I've got to say from the 8 or so I've tried, The Deep Ones and Lady of Shalott are both amazing. TDO has some sort of strange pungent scent that makes me feel 20 feet underwater, and LoS is aquatic with a hint of floral. Now I am not a floral girl at all - Shoggoth was too florally for me. But two days ago when I wore LoS I kept getting a whiff of delicious bouquets around me, and I finally realized that it was me. So I would definitely recommend those too, although I am still just a baby!