zmulls

I mourn the passing of this scent. I wear so many dark scents and this just popped off my skin, electric and full of bright colors. It was a favorite but I wasn't yet in bottlecollecting mode and missed my chance. I hope the Lab reformulates this and reintroduces it. I'd want this around.

I was generously gifted a bottle of this at a recent meet and sniff. I finally tested it today. My first reaction was, yup, just like the reviewers said, soap. But I smelled again -- it wasn't just soap, it was soap on someone's body. It smelled, not like soap in a dish, but like a warm body fresh from the shower, redolent of soap but glowing with musk..... Must try it again.....

I thought this was going to be another Brimstone, but moreso. I was expecting nothing but "fire smoke and ash" as per the description. But there are some sweet and noble notes all through it, making it something very special. It was a scent of great power rising from the ashes. It's a definite keeper. It's going in my impworthy pile for now, but I might promote it to bottleworthy after a few more wearings....

I was at a meet and sniff last Sunday and mentioned that I liked Troll, and got a wide-eyed response..."You wear TROLLLLLL????" or WTTE. Oh my yes. I find that the three things that make my skin sing are musks, leathers and vetiver, and it doesn't hurt if there are some spices around the margins. So Troll is so full of win. The vetiver has to be tempered to work on me, and there are so many lovely burnt and singed spices that my skin just dances to them. This is on my short list to get a bottle of sometime this year.

Honest to pete this is one of the only scents I have refrained from even testing. I got a frimp of this one before it was discontinued. I'm not big on foodie scents but I was curious about the seven deadly sins series. I choked just smelling it. I'm not a dessert person in real life, I can take or leave it, but this was every dessert ever baked. This was getting trapped overnight in a diabolical bakery. I couldn't bring myself to put it on my skin. But for anyone who craves the sugar, cake and chocolate scents, grab an imp of this before it's all gone.

Oh, it's definitely weird, but it's weird in the way I like. I usually can't do fruits and florals, but this melon is subdued and framed by such luscious dark scents. The juniper is made of win, and the heavy tobacco is in the family of dark scents I love (musks, leathers, etc.). I don't get the chili pepper and honey perceptibly, but they must be balancing each other out. I love this, and it's one of the few bottleworthy (for me) scents I've found. And I just scored an aged near-full bottle from a forumite.

As one of the rare "I love vetiver" members (and one of the rarer male ones), this was something I was anxious to try. When I reviewed my list of favorite scents, many of them have a touch of the evil "V" in them. But I've developed my own internal scale. Iago, Czernobog: Lovely amount of vetiver, makes me feel and smell good all over Malediction: A striking amount of vetiver, bordering on too much, but balanced out by other ingredients. A Countenance Forboding Evil: OMG. That is just TOO MUCH VETIVER!!!! So I was a little worried that Vetiver being the primary component of Highwayman, I would be too far up the scale. And at first sniff, I thought I was in trouble. That's certainly the first thing that hits you, and hits you *hard*. But I gave it time In several minutes, the other ingredients came out and mellowed and balanced the vetiver. Became a good strong scent but one with some sweet floral and leather dancing around it. Really nice. This one goes on my top ten list, and one of the only scents I will be hankering for a bottle of...

I was given a half-decant at a Meet-and-Sniff and tested it today. It's heady. When it went on I was in love with the autumn spices, but in mere moments there was something offputting and sharp, and moments later *that* disappeared. It's certainly a morpher as noted above. It settled into a pungent and redolent scent, not unpleasant but not too sweet or cloying, with a little decay mixed in. It was very, very interesting. Ultimately, this isn't going on my "want a bottle" list (and too bad, as there are a few bottles on sale in the For Sale forum), but I liked it a lot.

Oh, it's too perfect. Leather is always good for me, and the cognac is so enthralling. It is the best "dress-up" scent I've found. I try to stay away from LEs, as I can't bear to know that I will not be able to buy more. But someone frimped me a decant some months ago and I fell in love with it. I scored a half-bottle from someone and a couple decants and I'm hoarding it for special occasions. If this found its way into the GC, I would be a very happy masculine-scented BPALler.

Never mind.....I see your answer about sharing wishlists above.....

Can we view others' stashes yet, or is that coming later? I don't see how to click on someone's stash from their profile page (though I can easily get to "My Stash."

I realize this thread is a little dead but there are some wonderful scents listed on here. I just tried Satyr for the first time yesterday, and I really liked it, but I was wondering if it was a little too similar to Czernobog (which is how I stumbled on this thread). I totally love Czernobog and I don't know that I'd wear Satyr too much if I had them both. (Also, my skin is scared of cinnamon and I suspect there was a little of it in Satyr). When you think "animalistic," then "musk" always comes to mind, in all its various splendors. But I'm a guy, so musks and dark scents take to me. Not all the scents I like would work on most women. That said, Troll is a lovely dark musk with sweet burnt notes. But the most animalistic scent I have, and my absolute favorite, isn't a musk at all. Iago kills. It's a sharp wet leather with that nasty vetiver and a few other things. It's feral. It's a grotty bar down wet steps into a Hamburg Rathskeller. Again, I don't know that it would work for most women, but dab some on your boyfriend and see what happens.....

Yes, it's red and bright and hot and ......there's something.....reallly....*skanky* going on. Must be musks but this is very fragrant. Off-putting at first but very compelling. I swear this smells like two people who have just had sex and are getting up the energy to have some more.

Smelled very intriguing in the bottle. Got a good hint of the tangerine and vetiver when it hit my skin. And then.....it vanished. I can barely smell it. Mere minutes after applying it, it faded away, and I can only get vague whispers of what it was trying to do. I reapplied a couple of hours later and.....it disappeared again. Shoot, and I loves me some vetiver most of the time. Azazoth is a little too high pitched on me, though -- so high-pitched that only my dog can smell me.

I just ordered imps of Nocnitsa and Event Horizon from a Bpaller. Both have been on my "want to try" list for some time. Glad to know other guys have had success with them.....

Oh, Lust, you were irresistible when you started. But you were over too soon. I feel let down. And used. And cheap.

Oh my goodness, yes. Oh yes. How wonderful. I was worried that it would be a nice "lady" scent but it melds so nicely on me. Loved it from the first sniff. Maybe not bottleworthy but impworthy certainly. Interestingly, I let my 12-year-old son smell my wrist without telling him what the name of it was, and he said immediately it smelled like the sea. And there's no mention of sea/ocean/water in the description. (Of course, he may have been smelling remnants of Ogygia on me, but I tried that one five hours ago and have showered it off). It will go on my list of "spicy" scents next to Voodoo, and someday I'll have to pick a favorite to bottle-ize.

Um, ditto for me. This is a scent you want to put on and spend the first 20 minutes locked in a closet. It comes on too strong at first, and you have to let it settle in. The "clean ocean" smell is very potent, and very effective. I can't complain at all about the main goal of the scent. But like Ryvre, I didn't get anything else (at least not more than the barest trace). And there are many aquatics that work better for me.....ah well, farewell to Circe.

Eaarrgh. No, this one is more than disappointing. Aquatics usually work, and the blood note in Bloodlust is kind to me. But something in this is really disliking my skin. It went on astringent, powerfully so, and dried quickly down into a sad babypowder. Good fortune to all those for whom this works, on land or sea. Swap pile for me.

Much too strong out of the bottle. Kicks and screams and claws at you. But after 15 minutes, it dies down to a good sharp scent with lurking sweetness. An elegant troll-like scent. And still further in, the sweetness damps down and it lingers as a good dry thistly musk, without unnecessary pleasantness. I like it. Impworthy.

"Lab Full" is, I think, exactly the phrase -- and concept -- I was wrestling with! Thank you!

"smoke and clove?" I hesitate to recommend (what I think of as) heavily masculine scents to a woman, but if you're looking for smoke and clove you might look at Rumpelstilzchen (Marchen). ("Firewood and ash with an oddly otherworldly blend of patchouli, cardamom, nutmeg, black pepper, tonka, vetiver, and myrrh.") Lots of good smoke well-blended with the spices. No clove, but the nutmeg, cardamom and myrrh all have that sweetness. On me, it's just perfect. Worth a try for you, if the spice notes mix well with the smoke. Today, I'm trying Troll, which has "clove smoke" in it, but I don't know if I'm ready to recommend it. I need to try it another day. It's OK, but it might be too "dark" even for me, and not as well-balanced as Rumpelstilzchen.

I was trying out Dracul while out with a friend, and she told me that it smelled like Shalimar.

Wow, I really did it to myself yesterday. I've been testing a bunch of imps and decided to go through a few, rather than wear one the whole day. I wore Perversion in the morning for a couple of hours, was very satisfied with the skankiness of it. Then I put isopropyl alcohol on a cotton ball and cleaned it off. I tried Schrodinger's Cat for an hour or two, got all the citrus and mint and chocolate notes, and wiped that off. Then I tried Yorick, and got a good whiff of it. Later on, I showered before going out; and wore The Deep Ones to yoga. This morning, huge red blotches on my wrists. Now, I've worn The Deep Ones before, and I don't remember it causing a problem. I was trying Perversion and Schrodinger's Cat for the first time, and Yorick I had only tested briefly before. So, was it something in Yorick? Was it a delayed reaction to Schrodinger? Did The Deep Ones bother me, even though it didn't do it the last time? Or was it a reaction, the next morning, to the alcohol rubs? The only element that has bothered me this much before was the cinnamon in Faustus, which I stopped using.... ETA: Ah, it looks like, with this post, I am no longer a "wrist-sniffing wench"...that's good news...

I should preface that my skin chemistry loves dark notes. As a guy, my chemistry is quite different from most other posters. Florals and the like just are wrong on me, and dark musky smells thrive. And vetiver, so wrong on so many, is a great note with my skin. So Rumpelstilzchen is so much Win for me. Yes, I get the very strong smoke for the first few minutes. It reminds me a LOT of Brimstone. But where Brimstone is smoke, and just stays smoky for the duration, in Rumpelstilzchen the smoke settles in and becomes a blended note with the spices. The patchouli and vetiver keep it a strong masculine scent, and the nutmeg and other spices waft around them. I can't take scents where the spices predominate, but I like it when the spice notes are accents to the darker ones. So this is just perfect. I do very few bottles, but the next bottle I get will either be this or Czernobog. Not for everyone, clearly. But for guys who like things like Czernobog and Iago, or women who like strong notes, this is a winner.