As a dude, I will say that the following are my all-time faves:
DEE - Old books and libraries, incense, magic.
SAINT-GERMAIN - The rich, heady smell of a long life well-lived.
VILLAIN - Victorian cologne for gents -- very sporty.
MAGUS - Woodsy cedar
CASANOVA - Like Saint-Germain, citrusy but without the underlying musk and sharper.
MUTANT HOT-RODDERS - Biker leather, polished chrome and motor oil. Get lots of compliments on this one.
WILDE - Classic gentlemanly smell. Like Embalming Fluid in some ways, but the lemon takes a back seat and this smells very much like an elegant aftershave.
______________________________
What I like (and love):
BURIAL - Smells like burnt rubber out of the bottle and freshly applied, but changes very quickly into a dark, earthy (as in dirt) scent, with a faint hint of dead roses. I rather like it, but not as an everyday thing.
VICOMTE DE VALMONT - Sharp aftershave. The notes don't say anything about bergamot, but I smell a lot of it in this.
PORT AU PRINCE - Another weird transforming scent. Like burnt marshmallows and sickly sweet vanilla in the bottle, but changes to bay rum after about a minute, with no trace of the initial scent. Spicy and nice.
LIGHTENING - Clean and fresh. Good for a pick-me-up. Very much an awesome scent for dudes.
CROWLEY - Like Saint-Germain and Dee, but with extra animal magnetism.
FERRIS WOLF - Dark, sexy, manly.
SATYR - Very much like Ferris Wolf, only lighter.
BLACK FOREST - Pine trees. Good for a pick-me-up.
CZERNOBORG - Dark and fresh and manly, with a touch of pine.
EMBALMING FLUID - As sweet as I'll go, but after a few minutes the sweetness disappears and it's all fresh lemony goodness.
SILAS RUTHEN - "Opium smoke, opium tar, mandarin, dark musk, patchouli, tonka, vetiver, and frankincense". That about says it. Fairly long lasting.
CATHEDRAL - Pretty much like Magus, but leans more toward the incense, less cedar.
OMEN - Very fresh and masculine.
ODIN - Sharp, heavy on the camphor. I like this, but not for every day.
ANTHONY - Nice aftershave-smelling, but I have to say that this one is so light and mild it tends to disappear after awhile. I do love it immediately after application though. Also, other people seem to smell it long after I think it's faded away.
____________________________________
Scents I thought I'd like but don't really:
GOLDEN PRIAPUS - Pine is a masculine scent, but vanilla is not. Unfortunately, after wearing for about 30 minutes, all I smell is vanilla. Yuk.
DORIAN - Not for guys, definitely a girl's scent. More vanilla, makes my nosehairs curl.
SNAKE OIL - Thought I liked it at first, but it has that burnt marshmallow/vanilla scent, even after I've been wearing it for awhile. Not sure what to do with this one.
SAILOR'S DEN - Sickening vanilla, sweet beyond measure. Why is this called Sailor's Den? More like Den of Teenage Girls Chewing Bubble Gum.
DJINN - Almost like a super-sweet version of Burial. Unfortunately, the sweetness doesn't wear off.
YGGDRASIL - Smelled fresh and herbal when I tried it on, but it got really, really sweet after awhile.
___________________________________
Based on what I like, if anyone has suggestions, I'd appreciate some...