sqwook

Wet: *laughing* My notes here say "very weird." In this imp pack, Hesperides was by far the most unique.

Dry: Simple sweet mellow apple. I don't detect anything I'd identify as 'sturdy oak bark'.

Nice but not really me.

Wet: dry woods

Dry: Smokey woods mingled with an underlying soft incense.

Comparisons to other scents: Belladonna is the only other Rappaccini's Garden scent I've tried, and the soft herbal incense is very similar, but where Wolfsbane combines it with smokey woods, Belladonna is a green fresh-cut-plant topnote.

Wet: Green with a slight bite

Dry: The greenness drops away quickly, to a soft incense. Very interesting.

Comparisons to other scents: The underlying soft incense is very similar to that in Wolfsbane, but Wolfsbane is smokey woods instead of green.

This is one of my top loves. So it cracks me up to read that the one word I wrote for the review when Salome is wet is "gack!". Ah, how things change.

Dry: As this dries, the floral jasmine fades away bit by bit. The Egyptian musk, sandalwood, and oakmoss mingle for a very lovely, complex scent. An air of exoticness, faraway lands, mystery. Fantastic.

(I must admit, accidently dumping most of my imp down my blouse and onto the floor launched this scent from 'like it' to 'oh my gosh, love, don't waste another precious drop.' But hey, I'll take it. And my blouse, even drenched, still smelled pretty darn awesome, though it went into the laundry right away.)

Wet: Sweet green herbs.

Dry: Dries to be nice, cool, clean, but the herb twinge goes away,leaving it kind of nondescript. Clean, a pure-white spa might smell like this. Not me.

A scent locket might have saved this for me maybe, because I like the greenness when it's wet.

Comparisons to other scents: Clean like Embalming Fluid (but no lemon) or Phantasm (but no floral).

ADDED Oct. 26:

Wet: Sweet green herbs. Lovely fresh & green!

Dry: Green, sweet herbs. Dries to be nice, cool, clean, but the herb twinge goes away, leaving it kind of nondescript. I wish the tang of the green herbs had lasted!!!

Comparison to other scents: This is "clean" like Embalming Fluid or Phantasm, but with no lemon or floral.

Wet: Orange. LOVE.

Dry: Sweet ... orange, I guess, but there's so much more than that going on, and it's not overly hai-i-am-orange. Really nice. It might be slightly too sweet for me, but I'm willing to try it dozens more times to try to figure that out.

Actually, I got into BPAL because I was in love with Angel perfume by Thierry Mugler, yet it made my SO's sinuses act up. I was looking for an alternative (being an allegy for your S.O. is NOT GOOD) and discovered BPAL through friends. Now I'm thoroughly addicted. Many compare Xiu to Angel. It's definitely similar. I'm glad I have it -- and glad it got me into BPAL.

Wet: Green.

Dry: A sweet amber with a tinge of light apple, nice. I'm surprised that this is "black" amber because it feels like a very light, less deep/resiny amber to me.

Comparisons to other scents: The wet phase is a similar feel to the drydown of Yggdrasil but sweeter, light apple..

Update: I nearly swapped this, but I find myself reaching for it now - great for fall.

Wet: Honeyed egyptian musk.

Dry: Starts almond/cherry, but that thankfully fades. Smooth and warm, Much softer/quieter than I'd thought it would be - I don't sense anything fierce here. As I love egyptian musk & amber, I hanging onto it - worth retrying.

Wet: Fruity-rose

Dry: Beautiful. A true living rose with ripe fruits. For someone who doesn't like either overly-fruity or overly-rose, I'm amazed to say I love this. It smells happy, smiling, without guile.

Wet: Vanilla-orange.

Dry: To me, the milk-and-honey blend into an almost vanilla-type sweetness, combined with a nice rose. This is surprisingly good for a non-rose-or-vanilla person. I don't see myself reaching for it.

Comparisons to other scents: If I were looking for something with a feel of sweet-and-innocent, the brightness of Persephone or the assured calmness of Lyonesse seem more like me. (In feel - these scents are nothing alike.)

Sweet, pretty. A tinge of wweet apple. I can pick out each of the listed notes if I try. Interesting! Not something I'm likely to reach for (I go for things that are a bit deeper) but it's a great blend.

Dry: Vanilla, calm, soft. Not much oomph. (Please note that vanilla and I are not really friends; most people love the lab's vanillas, but I amp vanilla in a major way.)

Comparisons to other scents: To me, this seems very similar to Bastet somehow (which cracks me up - cat & mouse!) Compared to Lyonesse, it's slightly dirtier and less peppery.

*On retry just before handing over to a friend, the drydown has a sandalwood kick; not bad, actually. Who knows. Hm, might need to get an imp of this back...

So, on me, vanilla tends to take over, and it did here. Many many people love the lab's many fabulous vanillas. I wish I could join you - darn this body chemistry.

Dry: Deep, rich, with a hint of peach. Later in the drydown, it's very very sweet, almost too syrupy; I think it's the vanilla that's taking over. Vanilla stomps out any amber & sandalwood that might be there.

Comparisons to other scents: Similar to Imp, but Tamora is more super-sugary on me. Similar in feel to Bastet, Lyonesse, Mouse's..., but deeper and richer.

Wet: sparkling/peach

Dry: Peach spice, a slight pepperiness (is that the patchouli? I can't quite tell, it's faint), with a hint of musk deepness. The peach is overpowering the spice/musk. Good suggestion from Myrrha to gently shake the vial before using- I should remember to do that! Very nice.

Comparisons to other scents: Similar to Tamora in early stages but less super-sugary, which I prefer.

Wet: Sweet peach

Dry: The peach fades with time to merge w/musk/amber. Sunny, happy, sweet (but not cloyingly so).

Undecided on this; hoped for more amber/musk and less peach. But it is beautiful.

Comparisons to other scents: The peach lasts longer in the early drydown than with Imp & Tamora, it's much brighter/sweeter than those initially. The later drydown, though, is much more balanced and complex than those. (When tried together - I should wear them each alone to see how it goes. But you know, that takes days of elapsed time, to get to the full dry down, and I'm not sure I can be so methodical & scientific about it for multiple days in row...) For feeling, Mag Mell & Persephone have a similar happy brightness (though they are very different scents.)

Love, love, love.

Wet: Clear, green, sweet.

Dry: Really indescribable and - great. Energizing. This smells to me like a sunny day in a forest, green grasses underfoot, dappled sunshine filtering through overhead leaves, beams of sunshine lighting the nature trail. These are not dry deep somber woods, they are living green woods.

Note: I have an imp from a swap that I fell in love with, and a new bottle I purchased from the lab. The imp is sweeter and lighter, and has less bite. The bottle has an almost-evergreen note that can just quite be picked out and identified, whereas the imp is one indescribable blend of golden-green goodness. Maybe it mellows as it ages? The bottle's still great, though.

My first bottle. LOVE.

Wet: minty

Dry: Amber, calm, complex, beautiful. I love this.

The mint largely fades away, so if it's the mint that's giving you pause, I encourage you to try it anyway. Fantastic.

On drydown: Floral powdery amber. On me, the flowers are winning the battle over the ambers. I wanted to love this, but alas, too floral forme. It must be the myrtle/apple blossom, because carnation is one of the florals that's usually a winner.

This smells like sweet, sweet almond on me.

I swapped it, partially because it was high summer when I tried it and I couldn't envision reaching for it. Now that it's turning to fall, it occurs to me that it might be a good comforting snuggly scent.

(I should probably keep all imps for a full year to try in all seasons, but then my collection would really get out of hand!)

On me, this is a perfumey light floral. Not me, but very pretty!

Wet: Love the GREEN brightness of herbs, mint, lavender, lime - they mix to an almost pineforest scent.

Dry: Hm, all the brightness and greenness fades away to a clean soapy smell.

I swapped this; a scent locket might have saved it for me.

Wet: Smells like a candystore - sugary/fruity/sweet

Dry: A warm scent. Sweeter than I'd have thought given the notes.

On my own, I'd hang on to this one but unfortunately my SO seems to be allergic - perhaps the tulip/poppy?

I just downloaded the 9/16/08 spreadsheet and it's great - thank you! I'm just curious... how do other people handle their personal updating -- in terms of copying all your status and reviews note and color coding, if any -- from an older version to a newer version?

Hackess said she tends to put new stuff at the bottom of the sheet, so you can just copy that new stuff and paste it into your existing version.

(I, however, am avoiding this problem by trying my DARNDEST to stick to the GC - and then I don't need to worry about it. How long will this last? Only time will tell... )

I second Danse Macabre (and I imagine it's better as the weather is cooler). I also really like Haunted. (Especially, I discovered, layered with Snake Oil, but that's a completely different story. ) Embalming Fluid I like, too, but it's best to wait until summer weather.

Eternal was a nice light floral that was pretty enough, but not really for me- since you mention light florals, it may be worth a try.