Preconceived notions : This has milk, honey and bergamot in it, scent which I adore, well, when it's real milk and honey and Earl Grey tea leaves, but I don't know if they will work on my skin. Rose is just blah, and I have no clue what carnation smells like.
Im the imp : very spicy. And yet soft. I can't detect the milk and the honey, and the rose has yet to make an appearance. I would be tempted to say that I mostly smell the carnation, although I don't know what it smells like.
Wet on skin : Still spicy, perhaps slightly creamy. The milk - which, alas, as I had noticed earlier with White Rabbit and Milk Moon, turns sour on me - makes some teeny tiny appearances when I bury my nose in my elbow, and I catch those faint but worrying whiffs of sourness.
Drydown : The sourness fades away, thank God, and leaves only spicy creaminess. Still no roses, which is very very good. I don't smell the milk and honey and bergamot, but that's probably because my nose is uneducated; they must be there, rounding up the carnation, giving it that mellow creaminess...
I used this in a very hot milk-and-honey bath yesterday, and God was it gorgeous. It complemented the bathing ingredients wonderfully, no milk turning sour, no roses, just that carnation spiciness wafting over the steamy water...
Keeper? Well, if I hadn't by mistake used my entire imp in the bath, I'd say yes. But now I'll have to get a 5 ml...