A month ago, I traded off my Fruit Cake imp for a partial bottle of Creepy (about one imp's worth left in the bottle) from the 2006 Halloween blends. I fell in love with it immediately~ Yummy, delicious, granny smith apples dipped in butterscotch and caramel. I loved it so much that I started a quest for more! I started searching for imps to top off my lovely bottle. I got my second imp from a lovely lady here on the forums and it smelled just as delicious.
So, I HAD to find myself another bottle. I bid on one through eBay and won! Just got it today. However, it doesn't smell like anything like my other Creepy. Same year, same label, but (for lack of better words) off.
My first two Creepy were tart and juicy and crispy granny smiths with butterscotch and caramel, but my second bottle smells... dark. This is in the bottle. I tested both out on my wrists, one on each wrist and I can still detect the difference. So sad... =(
