Not sure if this is at all accurate anymore, so I am starting my wishlist post from scratch, and adding scents from here in as time as allows.

5 ml:
Bastet
Morocco
Dorian
Snake Charmer
Tell-Tale Heart

want to try:

salon
great he-goat
Les Anges Dechus
the smiling spider
Lot and his daughters
three gorgons
mad meg

LE/Discontinued:
Formula 54 (dream on)
Chaste Moon
Selkie
Bloody Mary
Trick #2
Minotaur
Count Dracula
The Castle
Tell Tale Heart

Carnaval Noir:
Midway
Freak Show
Snake charmer

Carnaval Diabolique:
Antonio, the Carny Talker
Phantom Calliope
Wulric, the Wolfman
Western Diamondback

GC:

The Wild Men of Jezirat al Tennyn
Akuma (for O.pal)
Ogun
Calico jack
Lust
Queen Alice
Brown Jenkins
The deep ones
Mad Sweeney
Morocco (I just want more)
Prague
Manhattan
Port Royal
The Isles of Demons
Mouses Sad & long tail
hemlock
The Red Queen
Bluebeard
Black Annis
Fenris Wolf
Hades
Obatala
Calliope
Clio
Malediction
Roadhouse
Anathema
Vixen
Haunted
Dragon's Milk
Y'ha-nthlei
Bewitched
Velvet