Keeping the list up to date whilst the swap section is down -Ok so we're back in business now I will update over there for BPAL stuff

Good

Vanilla, patchouli,mint,amber,lemon,grapefruit,tea ,cucumber

Usually

Red musk,myrrh,teak,oak,wine notes.cardamom.cloves,spice,incense

Sometimes

Violet,balsams,honey,blood,chocolate(usually not) cake,redcurrant

Bad

Roses,Jasmine,Pumpkin,Hot cinnamon

Other retailers

I have tried some Villainess soaps my favourite so far is Kill Switch

I would be happy to try more from here or similar

For perfume oils I have been sticking with BPAL as I don't want to have another addiction, but I'm up for enabling if I'm missing out on something fantastic.